At a family get together decades ago, one of my young nephews got into some mischief, did something “wrong,” and his mother challenged him sternly, “Billy, why did you do that?” I’ll never forget the look on the face of that five year old boy. His eyes glared with guilt and fear, he looked away, he stammered and then announced, “No!” His guilt was obvious to all; some of us smiled, remembering our youth when we had been there in Billy’s shoes. Years later In my clinical practice I was presented one morning with a six year old boy with impulse control issues (adhd) who had been rescued from an abusive family by his kindly grandparents. Sammy, as I’ll call this young tyke, eagerly greeted game playing as part of his treatment plan. This strategy was invaluable for a patient with these issues, providing an opportunity to teach respect for rules of simple board games, as well as patience. His moments of frustration and anger could then be explored in relation to behavior in school and family life. Sammy had very little control over his impulses, not able to accept having made a bad move and insisting that got to have a “do-over.” He even threw the board one time in frustration as I emphasized a simple rule. Often he would simply lie though it was obvious that he had cheated.
Both of these young lads had not reached the developmental stage of being able to admit having made a mistake, having been “wrong”, which is a basic skill in participating in the human race. The social body functions only if certain basic rules of organization, structure, civility, decorum, and respect for others can be adhered to. In each of these instances, they were off to a poor start in accomplishing this goal.
“Ego integrity” can handle critical feedback from others though it often still hurts deeply. I remember the impeachments of Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton. Each of them were deeply humiliated, and tried to lie their way out of it, but ultimately had to accept their fate and admit they had erred. In Nixon’s case, he had to accept the great humiliation of being forced to resign from office. Each of us have an ego and our ego is designed to attempt to save face; this is how the ego is designed. But when one has developmentally matured enough, his ego can have the integrity to accept the shame of humbly admitting, “I was wrong. I made a mistake.” In some contexts this might even be framed as, “I have sinned.”
When one lacks this ego integrity, and is is extremely immature and overwhelmed with shame and humiliation, the individual will go to any extreme to save face, even resorting to violence. This violence can be overt but also subtle, i.e. taking political form, and having a devastating or catastrophic impact on the social body. This individual cannot back down.
